Monday, September 19, 2011

Your Claws Are Showing

Maggie the Cat
Brick: What exactly is the victory of a cat on a hot tin roof?
Maggie: Just stayin' on it, I guess, as long as she can.



I just had this conversation on Facebook. It is probably symptomatic of 99% of my friendships and captures the duality of my personality.

Jackson: it figures that of all the characters in literature and film, u would identify with maggie the cat the most
Lo: Well, I feel a great affinity for Phineas in "A Seperate Peace" and Elizabeth Bennett in "Pride & Prejudice" and I feel that I share a lot of personality traits, besdies the whole cruelty thing, with Madame Merteiul in "Les Liasiones Dangerouses," but I think she's the closest fit.
Jackson: well, ur both southern and dramatic
Lo: I like that she's tenacious although she's ill at ease. She's resilient, and she loves a man that doesn't care nearly as much for her, and she just wants it all out in the open, you know? Even if it's bad, she'd rather have it all out on the table.
Jackson: she's also married to a raging alcoholic who might be a closest homosexual, a social climber, cunning, and ruthless
Lo: You say some of those like they're bad things. Mostly I acknowledge the cunning and ruthlessness, only when necessary. She actually did care about a lot of the Pollitt family besides the whole her scheming to secure her and her husband's position--I think she actually did like Big Daddy and Brick. And when she loves someone she'll do anything for them, even if it hurts her.
Jackson: again, it figures that u would identify with a tenessee williams character. u love the tragic poeticness of it all, don't u?
Lo: No, I just get the complexity of her personality and the struggles that she faces.
Jackson: it doesn't hurt that she has a gorgeous, broken husband and is played by liz taylor either, does it? yall do have that finishing school voice thing going for u, at least when ur not cursing up a storm
Lo: You know me too well.
Jackson: HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA
Jackson: sharon just walked in and said u remind her the disney girl in that movie with the d bag from 1 tree hill
Lo: A CINDERELLA STORY? You have to be kidding me.
Jackson: u would know which movie i'm talking about
Jackson: she said u sounded like the disney girl when she was giving the speech in the locker room, all righteous and wounded and what not
Lo: Is she talking about the waiting for rain schtick?
Jackson: she said yes
Jackson: it depresses me severely that both of u have seen this movie and know it this well
Lo: I own it, and I've seen it multiple times.
Jackson: ur life is sad
Lo: Is it possible to be Maggie the Cat and Sam (the Disney girl) and Madame Mertieul and Elizabeth Bennett all wrapped in one?
Jackson: in other words a cunning southern belle, a 13 year old virgin heroine, a scheming manipulating maneater, and a rash, prideful, independent young woman?????
Lo: That's pretty accurate.
Jackson: if anyoje could, it'd be u

(Five minutes later)

Jackson:
Jackson: [in a virgin disney girl voice ]waiting for u is like waiting for rain in this drought.....useless and disappointing!
Lo: I hate you.
Jackson: u love me.
Lo: I really do love that movie, though.
Jackson: HA HA HA HA HA HA HA

My life is ridiculous.

And so I leave you with the wisdom of Maggie the Cat.

Maggie: Silence about a thing just magnifies it.

Damn straight.


Saturday, September 17, 2011

Some You Lose, Some You Give Away


But oh, my love, don’t forget me as I let the water take me. 
||Florence & the Machine, "What the Water Gave Me"||

Oh yeah, life is bare, gloom and misery everywhere. Stormy weather, stormy weather, and I just can't get my poor self together. Oh, I'm weary all of the time, so weary all of the time. 
||Etta James, "Stormy Weather"||


The dream always starts the same. Somewhere in the dark of my sleep I become aware of a slow pulse of red light. At first, it’s dim, as if coming from a distance and through thick air. Something about the scene always terrifies me—although I’ve had the dream multiple times and now know what’s coming, even the first go around I could feel something wasn’t right. That I should run. But my feet are cemented and I stand a prisoner in the dark as the red light throbs closer and brighter. Eventually I can tell the light is coming from Christmas lights, the kind I used to have wrapped around my headboard. They gave my room a rosy glow. But these lights are different. Harsher. What they illuminate is tragedy at its worst. Eventually the details start to surface—the outline of the window panes, dark shadows of posters on walls, vague shapes of furniture. And then finally, the girl. Doll like, almost, she hangs from a pipe, limbs drained of life. I try to block the sight but my arms won’t move. I can make out the curve of her hair, the angle of her arm. And then just before I can see the grotesque sorrow written on her face . . . I wake up.

 I haven’t had the dream for a couple of months. The last time I had it, I was stressed out and sleep deprived during Practice Court. Before that, it surfaced a couple of times during the Summer of Celibacy. It happened most often at the tail end of my 2L year. It robbed me of sleep’s pleasure. And unlike most other dreams, I couldn’t comfort myself with a quick, “It was just a dream,” upon waking. Because it wasn’t just a dream. This nightmare happened—it serves as a real life example of the dark depths of sorrow and tragedy that will follow me the rest of my life.
               
The fact that this dream has resurfaced is symptomatic of the week I’ve been having. When it rains, it pours, so it figures that the thing I find most terrifying in my dreams has surfaced to keep me from the few hours of peace I afford myself a day. On top of that I have to worry about finding out if I pass the bar (which  creeps closer daily), finding a job, figuring out how to pay back my loans, how to make my car (which is falling apart) last, whether my ICD 9 codes are correct, why the hell my phone is strangely silent when it shouldn’t be, where I stand romantically, how to deal with most of my peers that I’m closest to being hundreds of miles away, worrying about Nurse’s mom who was in the hospital, worrying about my aunt (also my godmother) that was also in the hospital, and why the massive cocktail of drugs that I am on isn’t doing a thing to rid pressure, chills, and aches that are riddling my body. It’s just been one of those weeks.

But complaining wasn’t the point of this post, so excuse the digression. The reason this dream haunts me today, why that event will probably haunt a lot of people for a long time, is because there was no closure. And closure is key.

               
I’ve been thinking a lot about closure lately, and the role it plays in our lives. Closure in tragedies, closure in relationships, closure in books, novels, movies. One thing seems certain—most everyone craves it. Who hasn’t seen a story on Dateline ID where Lester Holt interviews a parent whose child has disappeared and the parent says, “I just wanted to know what happened to them, good or bad, though we were hoping for good.” Or in a tragedy such as a suicide, everyone wants to know why. Why did they do it? Could it have been stopped? Or in a relationship, where you obsess about what went wrong. Why did he stop talking to me for two years? And that’s when I realized what closure is—it is the absence of those nagging questions or of the drive to ask questions in the first place.

I have a friend—we’ll call him Professor X—and we have a very complicated past. We had a thing going on most of my senior year in college. It wasn’t healthy in the least bit. He wouldn’t commit which pissed me off and caused me to do stupid things. We were continually bickering. I was headstrong and so was he. It was a continual tug of war—who exerted the most influence over whom? Usually, I’ll admit, he won. And while a majority of the time I entertained notions of him in extreme pain, and although no one caused nearly as many of my tears that year as he did, he was a good kid, somewhere deep inside of the mess he’d become. It seems I have a knack for that—for picking diamonds in the rough. Only, I get them when they’re rough and other girls get them when they are emerald cuts.
               
Well, this guy, he grew into what I always knew he could be. He changed right before my eyes over the last couple of years. And what triggered that change was a girl. I always knew he had it in him—I just wasn’t the one to bring it out of him and neither was the parade of skanks that followed. Around this girl, he was different.
               
Professor X and his girlfriend broke up a few weeks ago. Since then, we’ve been talking constantly. We talk about his relationship, what went wrong, what he would do differently, what she could possibly be thinking. And trust me—I get the irony of the whole situation—I am counseling a boy through his grief that caused me a ton of it just a few years ago. But that’s the way life is—you never really see these things coming and it’s always the oddest shoulders you have to cry on when it matters.

              
I know that he’s having problems letting go. And I get why—he doesn’t have the closure he wants. He has questions he doesn’t have answers to. He has things he needs to say that he never got to say. He doesn’t know what she’s feeling or why she’s feeling that way. He is lost in the storm of his first true love and he doesn’t have the closure he needs to find his way out of it. And he doesn’t know when it will come.
               
Now that it seems I’m likely to join him shortly on the HMS Misery, we were talking tonight—him being the counselor and addict all in one--and I posed a question that I realized summed up our situations, and possibly every other situation, in a sentence.
               
When do you know when to say “Uncle” and give up?
              
Lacking closure can do funny things. It can keep you hanging on to the ghost of a person or a relationship. In my first brush with real, mutual feelings between myself and a boy, I freaked out and stopped talking to the kid—stopped taking his calls, ran off with another guy. It all was too close for comfort. When we briefly reunited in college, in a booze fueled talk, he mentioned that I had haunted him all those years—because he didn’t know what had caused me to leave or what he had done to make me stop talking to him. I thought it was weird at the time because I had never had that bad of a lack of closure—closure mostly denotes you care about something and at that point, although I’m not proud to admit it now, I really didn’t care much for the guys I was associating with. But then . . . karma.
               
AEG and his two years of utter silence came around. And I wondered about it. It ate me up inside—what did I do to deserve this? Where was he? Didn’t he miss me like I missed him? And I would swear to myself that I wouldn’t be whole until I had the answers to these questions. And in those two years, I’d find myself at drinks with a cute boy and AEG and those unanswered questions would creep quietly back in to my head. AEG haunted me.

               
Lack of closure can drive family members to look for the missing until they’re found. It can drive investigators to solve a crime. It can cause some of the greatest romantic novels to be written and the greatest movies to be made. It can cause some of the greatest songs to be created.
               
Closure, when it comes, is a chameleon. It’s different with everyone. It’ll hit you at the oddest times. With AEG, it wasn’t even speaking to him again—it was just the point where I didn’t care to keep asking the questions. For some, it’s when those questions are answered or when something new in their lives answers the questions for them. I sometimes wonder about Professor X and how his closure will come—how it will all work out in the end. The possibilities make my head hurt. I don’t know how it’s going to happen or when, but I know that he needs it—it’s the life raft out of this bad place his head is in. 
              
As I said, if we have to be on the HMS Misery and it’s going down, at least we’re on it together.

Round here we always stand up straight; round here, something radiates. 
||Counting Crows, "Round Here"||

If I may be allowed a slight digression (and I am, this is my blog), I laughed bitterly today when talking to Professor X about our respective situations. After weeks of both of us giving advice on perseverance, fortitude, praying, staying away from destructive impulses—I just had to laugh. Five years ago, if you would have seen us on a Friday night, we’d be a far cry from the rational, (semi)mature adults whining on the phone we are now. We were the lives of the party. We were likely challenging each other across a beer pong table, two conquerors facing off, Cleopatra and Caesar. I would have a smirk on because I knew that I was going to win the battle that night, and he was cockily self-assured because he knew he’d win the war. We’d flirt outrageously with others in the room but especially each other. And there was no mention of love, or settling down, or compassion for others. Compassion was a sign of weakness.
               
We were young. We were stupid. We had wild oats to sow. But still—the difference in the picture is striking. Like I said, it’s surprising the shoulders you find yourself crying on in life. It’s surprising where the most compassion comes from.
               
Closure, or lack of it—it’s a hell of a thing, isn’t it?
              
I leave you with Adele lyrics, because mostly, someone’s said it better, captured it better, than I ever could.


"Melt My Heart to Stone"

Right under my feet there's air made of bricks
Pulls me down turns me weak for you
I find myself repeating like a broken tune
And I'm forever excusing your intentions
And I give in to my pretendings
Which forgive you each time
Without me knowing
They melt my heart to stone

And I hear your words that I made up
You say my name like there could be an us
I best tidy up my head I'm the only one in love
I'm the only one in love

Each and every time I turn around to leave
I feel my heart begin to burst and bleed
So desperately I try to link it with my head
But instead I fall back to my knees
As you tear your way right through me
I forgive you once again
Without me knowing
You've burnt my heart to stone

And I hear your words that I made up
You say my name like there could be an us
I best tidy up my head I'm the only one in love
I'm the only one in love

Why do you steal my hand
Whenever I'm standing my own ground
You build me up, then leave me dead

Well I hear your words you made up
I say your name like there should be an us
I best tidy up my head I'm the only one in love
I'm the only one in love

Monday, September 5, 2011

What Came After


It’s been awhile. Graduation came and went, as did the Bar exam. And now I’m living the after afterall. So it's only fitting I begin with the new chapter of my life--and how I got there.

When the Road Doesn’t Go On Forever and the Party Does End

“The world tried to break me; I found a road to take me home. Ain’t nothing but a blue sky now—after all of my running I’m finally coming home.” ||Gwyneth Paltrow ‘Coming Home’||


Around February of this year the fear of what was looming was finally settling into my bones. In two months I would be ripped from the environment I called home for the previous three years and thrust once more into Valley life. I had taken a year off between undergraduate and law school and had returned to where I grew up. Growing up, I felt I didn’t belong there. On my year off, I screwed up a lot, trying to find where I belonged among my old friends—those who had left and returned, those who had never abandoned it in the first place. My main worry: Add three more years of schooling and a completely different way of socializing on to a personality who already felt like a fish out of water there and you’d get a disaster in the making.

I’d try to forget the nagging feeling that began eating at me that month. I drowned it out with a lot of Scruff’s nights and softball games with friends I knew I was soon going to be separated from. But the feeling would return, usually in the dead of the night or in a quiet moment during the day. How would it all end this time? I only kept in touch with a select few people from high school—most who had moved away or were in grad school in a different area. I only had two life-lines: my cousin, Cartman, who is like an older sarcastic brother to me and GP, a life-long friend and my cotillion escort. Other than that, I was on my own. AEG, the boy I usually compared every other guy to and dreamt about building a future with, had been my pillar at home for the last eight years, my anchor in the storm. But after he suddenly disappeared and ceased all communication with me for the last two years (for reasons that are still somewhat unexplained), I have been adrift—at least when it comes to being home.

Starting over in a new place is terrifying enough, but starting over in a place where you have already failed? That’s a whole new level of scary.

To add to this already mounting anxiety, I was duly informed that p2 was looking at summer jobs in the Valley. At the beginning of February we had still not spoken to each other since the events of the preceding Fall and generally it seemed both of us were trying to forget the other existed. One night we ended up talking to a mutual friend of ours and her boyfriend at Scruffy’s. Both of us were carrying on the conversation as if the other wasn’t there. Granted, I was dealing with p3 ridiculousness at the time (why, oh why, did I ever do that crap?), but the wounds were still raw.

A lot of my more “socially liberal” (best euphemism I could think of) friends liked to tell me right after things blew up with p2 that the only way to get over someone is to get under someone else. I’ve never been a fan of this saying or this way of living. However, it’s a piece of advice that gets thrown around a lot, and was dispensed to me liberally in this circumstance. Given p3, the youngins, and the general events of last Fall and Winter, I’m inclined to say that getting over someone by trying to get with someone else only leads to disaster.

NOTE: This is NOT a model for happiness.
Cue the interviews for summer jobs in the Valley. Aside from 12 hours of delays (screw you very much Southwest airlines), my stomach was doing somersalts at the thought of having to do interviews with p2. On the plane, the terrible thought struck me that I might actually be stuck having to deal with him in MY space, MY home. The Valley is a very small place and getting smaller every day. Mental images of p2 canoodling with girls I used to go to school with made me vomit in my mouth a little bit. And in the back of my mind, it bothered me that p2 still had such power over me. Maybe it was the lack of closure. Him and AEG had that in common. They were the itch in my brain I could never quite scratch.

I can remember that day like it was yesterday. The marble floors. The nervous law students milling around, pacing to and fro. The sideways glances of cutthroats sizing up the competition. Me, in my best suit, repeatedly checking my Betsey Johnson watch, looking at the floor just in case p2 suddenly walked into my line of vision.


Luckily, the boy I caught walking into my line of vision in a moment of weakness WASN’T p2. Instead it was an old friend I had grown up with that went to a law school in Houston. As we got reacquainted, I made polite conversation asking about his daughter and what kind of law he was looking to get into. While he was telling me about possible judicial clerkships he was looking at, p2 passed behind my old friend. He was wearing something typically p2, probably Brooks Brothers, and my stomach did one of those sickening thuds, recognizing the inevitability of a run in.

I was saved by a summons to begin my first interview of the day.

This reprieve didn’t last long. After the interview I went to the now empty waiting area and pulled out information about the next firm I was interviewing with—who their big clients were, how they got their start, the main partners, etc. While reading about a case that had involved State Farm, p2 himself walked into the main waiting area, offered a half smile and a small “Hey.”

Hey. HEY. 

That’s all it took. As miraculous as it seems, with that little word, the tension split and started to melt away. I gave him a smile and a small greeting, and before you knew it, we were talking like old friends. He asked me about p3, which we laughed about and commiserated over. We talked about his roommate, p1, and found common ground in hating his newest girlfriend, whom my friends and I had begun to refer to as “Trachea Snatcher” behind her back. Her kind of crazy seemed to earn a special ire from us. We talked about the jobs that we wanted and our pending plans for the summer.

And after all that tension, all that build up, we just went back to being friends in five seconds flat. Well, I shouldn’t say back to being friends. I’m not sure that p2 and I ever really were friends. In the beginning I used him and was awful to him. I’d tune him out when he actually tried to communicate with me. And then, you know, I fell for him. And whatever that whole thing was, it certainly wasn’t friendship. Friends don’t do the kinds of things we did to one another.

So I guess the accurate statement is that in five seconds flat we became the friends we never really were.

As I was summoned once more for an interview, p2 wished me luck and I did the same to him. It was five minutes into my interview when I realized that I meant it sincerely and that perhaps a summer with p2 around wouldn’t be the worst thing in the world.

My, my, how fast things change.

Jackson: "This Sounds Like the Plot to A Ridiculous Romantic Comedy."

“I want to be unique, I want to be your kind. I want to make you hate me then change your mind. I want to wear a skirt, I want to make mistakes. I want to kill you first and then take your name. I want to tear you apart, I want to make your bed. I want to break your heart, I want to break your head—so I guess this means we can’t be friends.” ||Lorene Scarfaria, ‘We Can’t Be Friends’||

Girl meets boy----oh wait, girl already knows boy.

You know how it is. My boy tales can never have just one leading male role. Enter GP, the aforementioned old friend.

Anyone that has known me for more than five minutes can tell you that very few things in this life make me nervous, the least of all, men. They can infuriate me, impassion me, placate me, sate me, but they never EVER make me nervous.

Well, that was until Christmas of 2009.

GP and I decided to get together for lunch. Him and I, as I mentioned, have been friends for as long as both of us can remember. We ended up going to different high schools, but still hung out. The real distance between us grew throughout college, both of us forging our own paths at different schools, hanging out with different friends. But nothing that is ever lost in the Valley is lost for long.

I’m not really sure how we started communicating again, I’m sure it was probably something as inane as Facebook, but we decided that we should start hanging out again. Which brings us to that lunch.

I won’t recount the lunch, because most of it isn’t memorable enough to entertain whoever reads this thing. Suffice to say this: there was a lot of verbal vomit on my part.

My verbal vomit would likely consists of a lot of legalese, stories of ridiculous law school shenanigans, mixed with copious amounts of "Dude!"

I was studying to be an attorney, and I enjoyed talking, but I just couldn’t stop the things that were coming out of my mouth. Apparently, trots of the mouth is my nervous tick.

Yes, I just said nervous.

As soon as lunch was over, I dialed CLit, still shocked.

“Yeah?” He sounded drunk.

“Dude. This guy just made me nervous. We were out to lunch and I just completely lost my cool.”

Silence on the other end.

“HELLO? CLit?”

“You’re kidding me, right? A guy made you nervous? Is this a joke?”

I could see my breath in the air. Rare, for the Valley at least. “No. It’s no joke.”

CLit laughed and spoke words truer than he could imagine, “Wow. You are in trouble. Watch yourself.”

I laughed the incident off then, but now, with the passage of time and hindsight on my side, maybe it was a little more significant than I ever would have liked to have admitted.

The nervousness didn’t stop there, either.

Fast forward to early Spring 2011, right after the previously mentioned interviews with p2. I had texted GP during a lull in the day and asked if he wanted to grab lunch. Much to my surprise he hadn’t eaten yet and his schedule allowed him to take off some time and meet me.

And the verbal vomit continued in full force almost a little less than two years later. GP, who ate and listened to me across the table with a small, amused smile, took it all in stride. I still think he got that he was making me nervous and got a kick out of it.

And the verbal vomit was further aggravated by the feeling that I was going to be alone when I moved back. Not alone in a romantic way, just, ALONE. The girl I had hung out with most when I moved back a year before was moving out of the country with her husband and toddler. AEG was a ghost. PAC and most of the guys I graduated with were in school or living in other parts of Texas.

I voiced this concern to GP and he quickly waived it away, finally getting a word in.

“Lo, don’t worry about that. You know that you always have me.”

I nodded quickly and continued on that tirade, but inside, I breathed a sigh of relief. At least there would be him. And possibly p2 to wean myself off the law school teet, so to speak. So I’d be okay, right?

At least if I found a way to ignore the nervousness.

Summer: Where the sand is your seat, waves kiss your feet, your friends outnumber the stars, and even the chilliest of nights are still warmer than the cold one in your hand.

“Tan lines may fade, but these memories are forever.”  – Nurse, after half a bottle of Jager at my 26th birthday

“You need to figure your shit out and go for what you want. And by ‘what you want,’ I don’t mean p2.” –Anonymous


There’s more stories from summer than I can or care to recount. Needless to say, I went in to the whole thing being apprehensive because I didn’t know where I stood with GP or p2 or anyone else for that matter. Perhaps the European put it best when he asked me the night before I moved, “What now?”

Truth is, I had no clue. I was dreading mixing law school friends with life long friends with family. p2 had gotten a job for the summer in the Valley and before school ended, we actually became friends and hung out a bit.

Of course, all that was good and well until the night of my graduation.

After spending most of the evening pretending I was far less inebriated than I actually was (mostly to keep my family from worrying), I let my guard down at Scruffs since I had 2Ls chaperoning and chauffeuring me around. I sung and danced with JFrank and toasted to the completion of three of the most arduous and terrifying years of my life. I celebrated with p1 and p2 and Nurse and AP. And of course, we afterpartied. It just so happened we ended up at p1 and p2’s house.

p2 and I decided to play a game of beer pong against Tennessee and another classmate. It turned into the most ridiculous game I’ve ever played. By the end of it, Tennessee was shooting me curious looks. Something was in the air and she could sense it. I had felt a twinge of familiarity earlier, but I had dismissed it as a drunk notion.

Could it be I was walking straight into the past I had taken so long to get over?

Too close. Luckily, not close enough.
Apparently, she was not the only one getting that vibe. Nurse, AP, and even p1 all made comments about it. And  pretty soon the warning signs were so bad that not even graduation drunk me could miss them.
No, I willed myself. This shit was over. OVER.

And, although some people may not believe me, it was. And as mistakes from everyone else’s past repeated themselves around us, I felt a sort of triumph in all of it. Ha. We had done differently. We were better than all that.

Weren’t we?

Meanwhile, I was adjusting to being around GP on a regular basis. With each passing encounter, my nervousness was fading, but I still occasionally had trots of the mouth around him.

This never manifested itself more than when I was caught off guard by the information that he was talking to some girl. A law student no less. An ugly feeling settled into the pit of my stomach.

Wait . . . was that jealousy?

I never get nervous. Probably following right behind that is how rarely I get jealous. This actually has been somewhat of a problem in my life as some boys equate my lack of jealousy to lack of caring, but I don’t really believe that’s really it. Usually I have what I want, so there’s no reason to be jealous. Simple as that.

Also, jealousy sucks. I’m kind of glad I don’t feel that way all the time.

So, of course, trots mouth me spouts off about how there’s no attractive or nice guys in the Valley. When GP guffawed at this, I looked him straight in the eye and said, “Oh, come on. You don’t count. I look at you like a brother.”

I should have “Insert foot here” tattooed above my upper lip.

Well, as things work out, I did mix law school and old friends and family. I actually spent most of the summer hanging out with p2, GP, and Cartman. They all got along fantastically, which is more than I ever could have asked for. We watched p2 run his game (which is surprisingly good and advanced—where did that swagger come from?) and GP bring around that law student . . . which just ended really, really badly. We laughed a lot and had a lot of fun. It was, in a lot of ways, the perfect summer.

One night p2 and I were having beers by ourselves in the Arts District. We were talking about everything and anything—a new thing for us, since we were actually listening to one another. He asked about GP. I admitted I didn’t know what was going on. He nodded and said probably the nicest thing ever.

“He’s a good guy, GP. And it’ll work itself out. I know it.”

If someone would have told me I would have gotten that ringing endorsement from p2 back in January, I would have laughed in their faces.

And that was one of the best things about the summer—p2 and I continued being really good and actual friends. Not to say that we didn’t back slide a bit. We did. But we remained friends and were careful not to fall into the same pattern that ended disasterously for us before. When he left for Memorial Day weekend, I actually missed him—which was huge, because I wasn’t just missing what he could do for me. p2 became a real person this past summer, at least in my eyes. I understand him better now and he understands me better now. We’re the way we were always meant to be.

As for GP, the nervousness abated and all that was left was warmth. There is something about him and the way I feel around him that just felt right and comfortable. Maybe it’s because we’ve known each other so long. Maybe it’s because we’re kindred spirits—souls who are slaves to our careers, but have the hearts of ten year olds. It just works. And it quickly became apparent to me that my life in the Valley would be a lot less enjoyable without him.

One of the qualities about our friendship that I admire most is that GP inspires honesty in me. I’d like to think that’s a two way street. We are both very candid about our pasts with one another. Of course, I know a lot of his because he used to date friends of mine. He knows little of my life since I moved away.
One day we were watching something and a conversation about cheating and home wrecking was brought up. Both of us have a lot of opinions on what people should do in these situations. We discussed those first. And then a pause brought back the things I regretted.

And although some girls would undoubtedly say that it’s not smart to share this kind of information with someone you care about, I did it anyway. I talked about p3 and finally told him the truth about p1 and p2. The whole truth. And I talked about how these sorts of actions were spurred and condoned by the environment I had been in. I accepted full responsibility for my actions.

This conversation made me realize how two months out of law school had changed my perspective on life and the things I had done. Everything seemed seedier now. It seemed easier to be a more polite and relaxed person. As much as I enjoyed my time there, I also realized the place changed me. And I was glad I was changing back. Back to someone better.

So . . . what is the point of all this? What about these two very different, but very important guys?

The point is that a choice had to be made. I had to choose what I wanted.

Way to be torn.

And the funny thing is that the choice really wasn’t so much about the guys—I realize that now. It wasn't like both guys were competing to get me--that was completely NOT the situation. It was more about the lifestyles they represented. Would I continue my shenanigan-full lifestyle from law school? Or would I want something that was calmer and more honest?

And this is where me turning 26 comes in.

I had the genius idea to turn my birthday, the last weekend in June, into a trip to South Padre Island. I hadn’t seen Nurse in awhile and I had been craving sand and sun. GP, ever the gentleman and far more organized than myself, planned the entire thing. He found us a house with a pool (‘necessary’ he said). It also happened to be p2’s last weekend in town, so it seemed the proper way to send him off.

We invited Cartman, Cartman’s cousin BRue (also a really good friend of mine), AP (who sadly couldn’t make it), p2 and BLo. And of course, Nurse. Nurse, who really is the best friend a girl could ask for, was excited to come down and meet GP.

The house was beautiful—GP really did a great job on it. As soon as we all got there, the drinks began flowing and my family came and took us all out to dinner. BLo even made time in his crazy schedule that had kept him gone for three weeks to come and have a few drinks with us. Of course, it being the Island, we all ended up at Wanna Wanna’s. The smell of the ocean and the feel of the sand and the breeze and having some of my best friends around me was something akin to heaven. As I was talking to p2 about him leaving, I realized I could not have wished for a better birthday.

I knew when p2 left the following morning, I was going to have a rough time of it. He was my last link to the BLS world and we were really good and genuine friends now. He had grown close to my family—he came to our Sunday lunches and played with my baby cousins—and we’d gotten close. And there were so many things I appreciated about him—his trademark scratchy laugh, the way he always carried a koozie like me, the way his really dark eyelashes brought out the light brown in his eyes, his impeccable fashion sense, that mischevious look he got whenever he was planning something or was in on some joke. I would miss him like crazy when he was gone.

But I, even after partaking in tequila with p2 (my birthday gift from him), finally figured “my shit out” as it was so eloquently put to me above. And I knew that this time, it was different. The summer had changed me, being away from BLS had changed me. My decision was well thought out, heart-felt, not tactical in any way (a rarity, at least before).

Instead of p2 and the life he represented, my old life, I chose the boy who was getting shit-talked by my cousin Cartman within my earshot. The boy with his cap pulled low, less fratty clothes and Rainbow flipflops. The hard working guy who liked dive bars and to argue with me about the merits of Miller Lite v. Coors Light (or “trots water” as he calls it). The one who called me on my crap and would warn me to “Stop lawyering him.” The boy who liked hunting and wearing boots and was constantly shaking his head in disbelief at me. The guy who, when his light brown eyes would meet and challenge mine, constantly struck me with this handsomeness that had been undiscovered for years. I chose him—not specifically him, but the lifestyle he represented. One of honesty, hard work, close family ties, limited debauchery, and simplicity.

And I’ve stuck to that decision ever since. I haven’t waivered, not even in the slightest. And the fact that GP kind of came along with this choice hasn’t been too onerous either.

So I made the choice and I remember the contentedness that followed it. I looked around. GP and Cartman were arguing about who would school who in the gym over a couple of beers. Nurse and BRue were having a deep discussion about music and life. p2 was telling me a story about some crazy divorcee. This is exactly how I wanted to remember my friends and this past summer. This was perfection. 

GP caught my eye and sent me a warm smile. I smiled back.

“You alright?” p2 asked me.

I smiled. Genuinely.

“Yes, p2. Everything is perfect.”

The next morning I woke to Nurse making bacon. I was in the kitchen, surveying the damage of the after party, when p2 walked out an announced he had to leave.

As we said our goodbyes and I watched p2 back out of the drive, I started tearing up. I actually started tearing up for p2. For the life he represented; the life had previously loved and lived to the fullest. We had both apologized for everything from our past. We had thanked each other for everything good that had since come from our friendship. For the first time ever, p2 and I were square. I’d never thought I’d be able to say that.

Nurse seemed to sense my melancholy after p2’s departure.

“You sad?”

“I almost cried. How fucking pathetic is that?”

Nurse smiled, and because she is a better person than me, she did not mock me for almost doing so.

I could hear the beginnings of life from GP from the hallway. He was on his phone with what sounded like a customer. The boy is always working—and I admire that.

Nurse turned to me suddenly, “Oh, and by the way, you totally undersold GP.”

“Hmmm, did I?”

“Totally. He’s a great guy.”

Maybe I undersold the type of life I was capable of having down here—even to myself. Now with time and a little perspective, I realize that I am going to be insanely happy down here, no matter what happens. 

Nurse and I are still close, despite living almost 400 miles away from one another. I have my family. I have GP. I have my friends. I have my profession.  More than that, I’m a better person here. I make better decisions.


So the after afterall? It’s pretty freaking fabulous. I've finally attained an awesome balance and there's no better way to live.

Wednesday, February 23, 2011

"But that's not fair!": U-Miami Law's Student Bill of Rights



While browsing Above the Law in class the other day, I came across another gem of an article by Elie Mystal. Apparently, some 1L at U-Miami was whining about her horrible law school experience. The remedy? Someone drew up a student bill of rights.


No. Seriously.

And now it’s being voted on by election at U-Miami Law. It’s seriously the saddest, whiny, unrealistic thing I’ve ever seen. Way to go U-Miami Law.

The following are the proposed rights and critiques of them. Initially, I thought I was just embittered because I went to a boot camp law school and was the only one (other than my classmates) who thought this was stupid. But no, the amount of mockery aimed at this atrocity on the internet has convinced me otherwise.

1) The right of the students to be given an unbiased legal education shall not be infringed.

It’s the first right in this U-Miami brain child and I already want to take an overpriced flight and punch this person in this face. An unbiased legal education? Seriously? When is education ever unbiased? For anyone that’s even been through grade-school (even a fancy private one) it is blatantly apparent to them that inevitably their educator’s biases and prejudices leak into their education. It’s part of what can make some educators so great and some educators so crappy. If you just shove the material down your student’s throats, it doesn’t go well. Teaching, be it good or bad, requires giving part of yourself to your students. It can inspire them. Or it can inspire them to hate you. Until we have robots spitting out statutes and precedent, legal education will never be unbiased. So unless U-Miami has a bunch of money to drop on said robots—and maybe they do with how out of control law school tuition is these days—this isn’t happening. Congratulations, U-Miami. Your list is already stupid.

2) No student shall be required to purchase course materials whose content does not appear on any graded assignment.

Look, we all hate how much textbooks cost, especially legal ones. But the fact is that most of the stuff assigned (at least in my experience) inevitably shows up on a graded assignment—namely your final exam. Of course, this might be because the school I went to is far superior to U-Miami or whatever. Who knows? But if your professor says buy it, you buy. They’re like drill sergeants people. You don’t argue with them; you follow their command. If you were looking for a learning environment that fosters equality between professors and students and cooperative learning, you should have gone to grad school for Peace Studies. You are in the wrong place and might want to consider dropping out. Now. Before you owe some ungodly amount of money and realize you hate the future you’re racing towards.

3) The right of students to take exams that proportionally cover the material discussed in class and presented in the required reading shall not be contravened.

“Proportionally cover the material discussed in class and presented in the reading?” Look, once it’s assigned or covered in class, its fair game. Who cares what the proportions are? You’re responsible for all of it! And this isn’t just a law school thing—this happens in college and even in high school. I don’t think it’s asking too much to ask a student to recall something they were assigned in the reading. Or in class. What if the test is mostly what was in the reading and not what the professor talked about in class? Rule 13. Get over it, counselor.

4) The rights of students to review any exam within a reasonable amount of time after the grade of the exam is released shall not be violated; nor shall the right to review the exam with the professor in person be violated, as long as a meeting with the professor is reasonably feasible.

This is probably the “right” I have the least beef with. Why? Because it is reasonable. Although, let’s be honest, this might cause a multitude of students to seek to review their exams. And for some professors and adjuncts, they don’t have time to break down an exam for 100+ students. Also, there’s a lot of “reasonably feasible” and “reasonable attempts.” Oh, legalese. You make me a sad law student.

5) Students shall not have to wait an unreasonable amount of time to receive their grade on any graded assignment.

Professors are busy. Classes are big (or so I hear; my school is pretty small). Things get backed up. Even so, I get the frustration at not having your grades. One quarter my professor who went on sabbatical still got his grades in later than every other professor. But it’s a fact of law school life. Sucks to be us. Go to a different grad program.

6) The right of a student to receive a clear explanation from the professor as to how the student received their grade on any graded assignment and the right of students to submit all graded assignments anonymously shall not be infringed.

Anonymous grading is great in theory. But does it work in practice? I’m sure at every school there is some professor who everyone knows doesn’t anonymously grade. There’s at least one at my school. And I kind of get where that prof is coming from—I think how much you try in class and who attentive you are should factor into your grades, at least a bit. As for a clear explanation from the professor as to your grade, good luck. Some professors are really straight forward about the way they grade, others are vague and ambiguous. Maybe they didn’t like your word choice. Maybe they didn’t think you got the concept across. Asking for precision and clarity in a vague and highly subjective practice is asking for a slight miracle.

7) Students shall not have their legitimate questions about course content and course management ignored by the professor unless it is unreasonable for the professor to answer the student's questions and/or the student failed to make a reasonable attempt to answer the questions before asking the professor.

Okay, I admit, it sucks when you’re confused about some principle of law and the prof won’t help you. But it’s so rare that this situation arises. Most professors are ready and willing to help—as long as you don’t have a question after every single class period. However, I did have one professor whose reply to my question was, “We’re you not in class that day?” He did this to pretty much everyone. And it is frustrating. But did my classmates and I whine about it? No. Instead we found an attorney and some upper quarter students and asked them our questions.

8) In class, students shall not be expected to know material that was not covered in the assigned reading for that day's class, nor covered in any of the lectures and/or assigned readings prior to that day's class.

Stop whining. I go to a boot camp Socratic method law school and you know what? During our trial boot camp class I got stood up, along with some of my other classmates, and inevitably we got asked about things that we hadn’t read yet. You know what we did? We tried our best. It happens. Get over it. Basically allowing this amendment would allow someone not to be asked a basic property principle while in Trusts and Estates. And that is just stupid. Like this list, U-Miami.

9) The right of student to not have the composition of their grade changed from what appears on the syllabus during the semester, given that the professor does not notify the class of the change and the majority of the students do not support the measure, shall not be violated.

LAW SCHOOL IS NOT A DEMOCRACY. IT IS A DICTATORSHIP. BOW TO THE WILL OF THE ADMINISTRATION AND PROFESSORS! Allowing the students to have a say in how their grade is composed sounds stupid, even being a fellow student myself. I am getting increasingly frustrated as I read these.

10) No student shall be responsible for, in any graded assignments, material covered during a make-up class that is not recorded and whose recording is not made easily accessible for all students.

I’m about ready to punch my computer in frustration. You know what U-Miami? This is not kindergarten and your law school professors shouldn’t have to hold your hand. I’ve had to miss make-up classes for various reasons—I have a job, another scheduled class, etc. Did any of my professors record it? No. Did any of us ask them too? No. We didn’t want to get laughed out of their office. You’re responsible for the material, regardless. This is why you make friends in your classes and you borrow notes from them. Seriously, U-Miami? Seriously?

11) No student shall be responsible for, in any graded assignment, material covered before or after the class's scheduled meeting time unless a majority of the students agree to elongate the class.

You only want to elongate class if a majority of the students agree to it? Do you? Law school is not a democracy. Once again, if that’s the type of education you wanted, you should have gone to some artsy-fartsy grad program where the tuition was lower and mental torture was less. Didn’t know what you were getting into? Not even law schools presented in the media seem fun or models of egalitarian society. And if you still managed to be ignorant of that and went anyway, as soon as you found this out, you should have gone running to an MBA program. Elongated classes are just a fact of life, as much as we all wish they weren’t. Sometimes the professors do drag their feet and sometimes there’s just way too much material to cover before an exam. This is just a fact of life. Yes, it sucks to sit through marathon sessions that weren’t even scheduled on the syllabus. But you don’t want an incomplete picture of the law. Also, the professor is pretty much king of his classroom realm, unless their behavior is extremely abhorrent. They’re like federal judges in that way—absent some really scandalous behavior, the administration is likely to pat you on your head and send you on you merry way. Oh, and while I’m typing this, my professor just scheduled a class outside of the allotted hour. Did anyone complain? No. Someone did try to get him to bring us pizza, but that’s just great negotiating skills at work.



And perhaps, my most scathing critique of all—the likeliness of this getting enforced. As in, it’s probably somewhere near zero. Even if the U-Miami SBA gets this passed by vote, who is to say the administration is going to follow it? This is not the Magna Carta, as much as they’d like it to be. There is literally no interest for the administration to adopt this document. Why? This isn’t Egypt and the U-Miami law kids are not demonstrating for democracy and change. This is a situation where the students can complain all they like, but it won’t make a difference (maybe a Communist China analogy is appropriate here? I’m not sure) because in this economy, there are many recent college graduates who would gladly take your place—even with that place being the underling in the law school hierarchy, subject to the whims of the administration.

I’m glad things like this don’t happen at my school. As one of my classmates said when we found the article on Above the Law, “The first thing _____ Law School taught me was that I didn’t have any rights. And I did that to myself.”

Another classmate of mine had the following opinion after reading the bill of rights:

This is what I gathered. "We are in law school, but...we have reverted to a time when we were three and had no argument skills other than 'but that's not fair!' We live in Miami and think school should be easy so we can lie on the beach and do no work to earn our J.D. We will also probably be held in contempt every day for bitching when a judge schedules something not originally on our calendars. But at least we will be tan."

It doesn’t get any truer than that. I think the U-Miami kids need to stay out of the sun—that could be the only reasonable explanation for this tomfoolery.

As my favorite professor said in response to a student's assertion that a case result was unfair:

"Fair is something that happens in Dallas in October. It ain't October and this ain't Dallas, counselor."

Word.




Wednesday, January 19, 2011

Hey Jealousy

The Boston University Facebook Scandal


Envy aims very high. - Ovid

There's no way that blonde bimbo got the high A in contracts!

Oh, law school. You give me so much material to write about. Repeatedly.


Yes, it’s that time of year again. After having to listen endless 2Ls complain on and on about their T&E and Biz Org grades [trust me, I’m sure they’re just as bitter about my class’ constant complaining about Practice Court] and watching the lower classes speculate about who will end up on law review [who cares?] and receive their first grades, it is time for another grade envy tirade.

And mirroring my complaints was a lovely little piece on Above the Law by Elie Mystal about a 1L at Boston University who posted his first semester grades on his Facebook. Not just “I did great!!!!!” or “I kicked LARC’s ass!!!!” Oh no, that would be far too subtle for this 1L. Instead he did this:

Civ Pro: A
Legal Writing & Research: A
Torts: A
Contracts: B+

I mean, there are tons of things that I complain about being on Facebook on a daily basis (creepy 3-D pictures of baby fetuses, I’m talking to you), but seriously—why would anyone on Facebook care to see an unofficial transcript of your first semester in law school? I’m friends with my mom on Facebook and I hope she’d have enough sense that if I did this sort of thing, she’d slap me for being so prideful and arrogant. Granted, if I had these grades, it might be worthy of a Facebook post, because it’d damn near be a miracle. But you get my drift.

But perhaps even worse than people not caring about this kind of thing is the people who do—and get massively offended by it. When I see this kind of thing [yes, it happens at my law school too] I roll my eyes and go on to the next status update. But some people get seriously upset. It’s insane. They will moan about this crap for days. Of course, these tend to be the people trying to figure out who is going to be on law review and who got the high A instead of them. I’ve talked about the petty academic envy that goes on at law school at length before (see my previous posts).

Mystal comments on how this is a gigantic waste of time—which I agree with. There are so many other things to spend your energy on, and a douchetastic classmate is probably not one. Are you upset about your grades in comparison to the douche's? Stop complaining, get off Facebook, and study more. As Mystal points out, instead of complaining, if you’re truly offended or whatever, spend that energy doing something productive, like on trying to steal his girlfriend. [Although this is just as petty, at least it’s far more entertaining and won’t make me want to gauge my eyes out.]

People, unless directly asked, no one wants to hear about your grades. One of two things happens when you talk about them: either you did better than others, which can earn you social ire, or you did worse and are going to feel inadequate. Actually, a third thing: I am going to tune you out because I’m worrying about how to phrase my Motion for Judgment on the Verdict so I don’t get a memo. It’s a lose, lose, lose situation, people.

Also, realize that if you are posting statuses like this, you will forever be labeled a douchebag. Think initial impressions don’t count? My class still refers to a kid from the quarter below us as “doucher” because of how he filled out his law buddy form.

I realize that some people, ahem, the “A plus having, Top-Gunneresque gunners” as Mystal puts it, may be frustrated by this. But there’s a reason that there is this unspoken law that you don’t do this: as stated above, you’re only going to lose, lose, lose.

In fact, the only way you could possibly win is if an attractive, dumber member of the opposite sex decides to buddy up to you to raise their grade the next quarter/semester. But rest assured, they’ll be back to hitting on the mediocre hottie that ignores your grade superiority statuses on Facebook in no time.

Like I said, you ultimately lose.

Mystal and I are in agreement that the only way to combat this kind of stuff is to not care. But we all know that’s not going to happen. Half of the school will not care and label you a douche, the other half will hate you for doing better than them in some class [and usually ¼ of this group will pretend NOT to care and then proceed to trash you whenever possible].

Get on it. It's that time. Again.

People, the only person that determines your grade is you and how hard you work. Well, that and your professor [you don’t control him, at least, the Dean hopes not]. And how smart your class relatively is [it’s easy to be top of the class when your class is full of mouth-breathing cretins]. You know what, the grades are there and you can't control it—it’s just best to embrace them and keep trucking on.
So stop narrowing your eyes at the douchebags and focus on you—because I guarantee you no one else is going to give a crap about how much of a douche that gunner in your 1L class was when they’re looking to hire you. Plus, in my experience, these kind of people eventually get theirs. Karma is a beautiful thing that does not require your energy to operate.

Back to the books, people.

The Georgetown Law Cheating Scandal
 
Rumor has a hundred tongues, a hundred mouths, a voice of iron. - Virgil
 
Telephone: The Adult Version
 
Elie Mystal started out an article on a Georgetown Law cheating rumor by comparing law school to high school. Personally, I think it’s more akin to middle school, but you get the point. Mystal bemoans the de-evolution to childishness that everyone seems to experience in law school, while repeatedly pointing out he/she (?) didn’t go to state school. Well, surprise, it’s the same for us that did. We just probably matured in college with crappier vacations and older cars.
“Law schools seem to be crawling with snide, backbiting saboteurs. Playground bullying is replaced by intellectual bullying, and all sense of collegiality falls prey to petty competition.”

Well, Elie, you said it better than I possibly could. Before you start to thinking that my whole attitude about the professional school thing savors of bitterness, I must say that there are some great people I’ve met at law school. There are good, honest people here. They’re just far less noticeable than the ones Mystal talks about. Also, they cause less problems.

So what’s the solution? Mystal advocates doing what a Georgetown 1L did when he found at that someone in his section was spreading a rumor that he cheated on his civil procedure examination: he confronted it and handled it like an adult, while managing to attack aggressively and push back at the intellectual bully—and hard.

Cheater, cheater; cheating is a reputation bleeder. There literally is no faster way to turn law students against one of their own.

The unnamed Georgetown 1L emailed his entire section over break and confronted the accusations upfront and called the gossip monger out:

Hey section [Redacted],


Some students in our class told me they saw me cheating on the civil procedure exam. Apparently they feel like they are going to do me a favor by not reporting me and instead just talking shit about me and trying to make into a pariah or something. What they saw was me copy pasting my essay into google docs to do a character count that didn’t include spaces since I was using open office and that does count spaces.



Anyway don’t take my word for it, anyone who is convinced I cheated can report me to the ethics counsel. I don’t mind since my time stamp should absolve me. Don’t do me any “favors”.

 
Happy holidays and new years all,

 
Badass Georgetown 1L


[Okay, that’s not what it actually was signed but you get the point.]

Wait . . . you mean he dealt with this in an adult fashion? No counter rumor mongering or fake niceities? Or going to complain to the Dean? This email is genius! He basically backhanded the rumor with an ultimatum: Report me or STFU. [As Mystal put it so eloquently.]

Oh, rumors . . . one of the many delights/horrors of law school. Trust me, I get this kid’s annoyance and frustration. Things tend to get blown out of proportion, twisted, and exaggerated. Perhaps this is why I felt such affinity and amusement while watching Easy A. As I’m sure most people could say, “Rumors of my (slutiness/ruthlessness/callousness/alcoholism/cheating/lying) are greatly exaggerated.” Yes, that’s probably true, but the information is still out there. And fighting that information is the biggest battle of all.

What if everyone dealt with things like this Georgetown 1L? I admit, law school would lose some of its intrigue, but would that be a bad thing? Of course, the problem is most people, even lawyers, aren’t fond of confrontation. Had I been placed in a similar situation, I probably wouldn’t have had the stones to do what this kid did. Instead, I probably would have just bemoaned the rumors in a bar and trying to ignore the accusatory glares. Actually, I totally know this is what I would’ve done because this is how I’ve handled every single rumor about myself that’s ever gotten back to me.

Like in most things, I find myself part of the problem, not the solution. But hey, a majority of us are the problem, so that makes me feel a tad better. Also, the first step is realizing I’m part of the problem, and in my defense, I’m trying to change. So there’s that.

Still, the bravery and pure badass-ness of this Georgetown 1L are an example of what we should strive for.

Also, I need to meet this Elie Mystal person—their view point is refreshing and the narcissist in me loves that it’s similar to mine.

Lawyers & Long Islands

You do anything long enough to escape the habit of living, eventually the escape becomes the habit. – David Ryan
Yes, they actually sell these on zazzle.com. I wonder what your DUI clients would think about it?

One of the most soul crushing things about beginning law school is orientation. At least at our school. I mean, I get why it’s necessary, but you sit around for three days wondering if this is a sign of things to come. [FYI: It is.] The students, of course, feel it could be streamlined. Around day two, when the Dean walks in to talk about substance abuse, it’s all you can do just to appear interested and attentive.

Of course, the Dean had a point, one that many of us discounted the importance of.

Iris Erlingsdottir published a recent piece on HuffPost entitled, “Rehab for ‘Terminally Unique’ Lawyers.” In it, Erlingsdottir addresses addiction and its prevalence in the legal field. And yes, I know we’ve all heard it before, but I wonder how dangerous our discounting the value of the message is.

At the beginning of the article, Erlingsdottir recounts how in her old university days it was joked about how the blood bank truck would skip the law school because, as the nurses said, “It’s not worth the time and effort, because the blood will evaporate before we make it back.”

The too drunk 1Q, the drunk first year clerk, the drunk first year attorney who discovered that big law is not for him . . . . seem familiar?

Pretty hilarious, right? That’s when I remembered how a classmate my 1L year had commented that the blood bank truck would do a lot poorer than it should because too many upper quarters were hung over. I had laughed at the joke at the time, but now I wonder if it’s actually so funny. Are we laughing in the face of addiction because it’s inevitable?

Studies have shown that lawyers have twice the addiction rate of the general population and are three times as likely to be depressed. Really, considering the type-A, perfectionist, insecure overachievers professional can attract, this isn’t all that surprising. So I guess it poses a similar question to that I asked yesterday: Does law attract addicts or does it create them? And furthermore, does it hamper their treatment?

Lawyers are “notoriously reluctant” to seek help for their addiction issues. Erlingsdottir addresses the idea of “terminal uniqueness” and lawyers in relation to addiction. “Terminal uniqueness” is apparently a recovery term that refers to the reaction of newcomers to AA or any other treatment program that “these people aren’t me, my problem is different.” Lawyers training apparently seems to be a roadblock to recovery, as is the fact that they are in a profession that is licensed, monitored, and guided by ethical rules. At least, from what I gather, the argument that trying to stay sober is hard enough, but trying to stay sober in a profession such as ours brings on added challenges.

Law school and the profession itself fosters and environment that is secretive, competitive, stressful, and adversarial. As the article points out, it encourages isolation and not sharing, because that can be seen as weak and vulnerable. And before you waive this away, I challenge all of you to think back to your first year writing class or moot court. Everyone knows someone who hid a book or a statute or refused to share it with someone because of the competitive environment.

First one with a mult-million dollar verdict gets a bonus!

According to Harvey Hyman, a CA attorney and CEO of Lawyers Wellbeing, Inc., talks about how this profession makes its practitioners resistant to treatment:

“There is no doubt that lawyers are much more difficult to treat. They think that they are special, different from others, too smart to be addicted. On top of that, they’ve been trained to argue against everything and everyone, and they are extremely critical. They’ll use their brains to pick apart the program and everyone and everything associated with it, and this possess a unique challenge to anyone who treats them . . . They are not used to and have great difficulties getting in touch with their feelings, which is a huge part of getting and staying sober.”

Is this starting to ring a bell? I’m pretty sure I’ve gotten at least twenty lectures since I’ve started law school on how different and special lawyers are, about how we have to be logical, not emotional, about how we’re so fundamentally different from others.

Lawyers deal with so many other peoples’ “problems” all day, it’s no wonder they hardly have time to work on their own. Add onto that the stress of maintaining a good reputation in a practice where reputation matters and it almost seems like we’re programmed to fail.

And how bad is legal profession failing?

Note: We're epically failing. Also, I'm sure this stance is familiar to you, especially after a Contracts exam.

The ABA estimates that 20% of all lawyers have an alcohol dependency or abuse problem. 20%. That’s 1 in 5, people, the highest of any profession. And the depression rate? The average among U.S. adults is 6.5%, among lawyers it is 20%, and among law students it is 40%. I guess that makes me feel a little bit better about hating my life the last couple of months, but it’s scary at the same time. Adding to this problem is the view that most law schools are “way behind” in educating their students about alcohol dependency and making them be more self-aware.

Hyman claims later on that “law schools are a nursing ground for breeding alcoholics.” Is that true? A doctor later chimes in that law students are known as being the hard drinking group among students and that the culture is you live hard, you work hard, and that “drinking and addiction is a little bit a part of the legal culture.”

We're done with Memo II/4Q exams/big trial! Party time!

As I was going through this article, I thought about a recent sporting event here held at my current school. Some undergrads from my alma mater came into town and they hung out with a couple of law students. I can’t count the number of times someone told them they needed to “buck up” and “learn how to hang” now that they were with law students. I thought of the mixers with law firms I’ve been to with open bars. This has become such a huge part of the legal culture, sometimes I think we don’t even reflect on it because we don’t realize it’s so outside of the scope of normalcy.

I think addiction, not just to alcohol, but to anything, is a huge problem in law school. Luckily, I attend a school where our addiction problems tend to be fewer than some of the other schools my friends have attended. Of course, this is a bit baffling, since we are known as a harder and more stressful law school. Literally, one of my state school 3L friends refers to our 3L year as “The Holocaust.” [No joke.] But we’re in a smaller town, there are less distractions, and because of the religious community, such behavior is judged and frowned upon. Not that it stops most people completely, but you know, the stigma still is there. Unlike some of the other schools in town, organizations are not allowed to host open bar mixers or anything of the sort. How much this actually cuts down on the alcohol abuse is anyone’s guess, but I can tell you—our school is not nearly as bad as others. At least when it comes to alcohol or drugs.

Ah, the numerous nights were sleep eludes you. Instead you worry about your upcoming exams/the direct examination you have to do tomorrow/how you're going to pay your loans back when you don't have a job.

What a lot of people tend to forget is that you can be addicted to other things, as well. Whether it’s religion, physical intimacy with others [ahem], working out, staying healthy, WHATEVER . . . it seems like everyone has an addiction in this place. Some of them are innocuous . . . really, how much can an addiction to “Real Housewives of Beverly Hills” hurt you in the long run besides tending to make you shallower and more insipid? But they are addictions just the same. And I think it’s this addictive attitude that can lead to some of the excess and debauchery I bemoaned in the previous post.

So what should law schools do about it? I haven’t a clue. As someone still immersed in it, I probably don’t have the best perspective. But I do think the littlest things can help. Fostering open communication may be a start, but to be honest, that has an ice cube’s shot in hell of working right away in such a competitive and selfish environment. Our school recently started giving yoga classes. I know that seems dumb, but the littlest ways to de-stress that don’t involve inebriating substances is a start.

I’m not saying I don’t get the mechanics of how the situation works—trust me, I do. The first thing out of most people’s mouths after an extremely stressful assignment or advocacy session is, “When are we going to the bar?” But perhaps it’s like John Selden said: It's not the drinking to be blamed, but the excess.

Look, I’m not saying that everyone had a problem or that everyone will necessarily develop one—that would be an overstatement of the situation. But there is a problem in the legal profession and in law schools, and it’s one we don’t like to talk about. I don’t know much about AA or other treatment programs, but I’m always hearing that the first step in recovery is recognizing there’s a problem. So maybe that’s what we need to do . . . discuss it more openly and stop shoving our skeletons in the closet.

Just a thought.